Buying guide

Sponge Filters

Our pick

Hikari Bacto Surge Small

Choose the Hikari Bacto Surge Small for an air driven sponge filter in an aquarium up to 40 gallons.1

Compare the alternatives

Why this one

  • The Hikari Bacto Surge Small uses a weighted base, making it a choice for placement on the aquarium floor.2
  • The Hikari Bacto Surge Small does not include an air pump, so plan to supply one separately.1

The alternatives

Other contenders

  • Aquatop CAF-10 Internal Sponge Filter

    Choose the CAF-10 for a tank within its 10-gallon rating when its 2-inch sponge footprint suits the available space. The weighted filter accepts an air pump or a compatible powerhead; allow room above the sponge for the uplift tube.34

  • Aquatop CAF-25 Internal Sponge Filter

    Choose the Aquatop CAF-25 for a tank up to its 25-gallon rating when you want a weighted filter that can run with an air pump or a compatible powerhead. Check its 3.125-inch sponge diameter against the available space.56

  • Aquatop CAF-40 Internal Sponge Filter

    Choose the CAF-40 for a tank within its 40-gallon rating when there is room for its 5-inch sponge. Its weighted base sits on the tank floor, and it accepts an air pump or a compatible powerhead. Allow room above the sponge for the uplift tube.78

  • Hikari Bacto Surge Large

    For an aquarium above 40 and up to 75 gallons, choose the Hikari Bacto Surge Large for its higher stated tank limit.1

Compare the options

5 products

Compare models side by side

Models in this comparison

Every specification for these products
SpecificationHikari Bacto Surge SmallAquatop CAF-10 Internal Sponge FilterAquatop CAF-25 Internal Sponge FilterAquatop CAF-40 Internal Sponge FilterHikari Bacto Surge Large
Rated tank size40 gal1Up to 10 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 10 gallons for CAF-10.)3Up to 25 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 25 gallons for the selected CAF-25.)5Up to 40 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 40 gallons for CAF-40.)775 gal1
Base typeWeighted base2Weighted base4Weighted base6Weighted base8Weighted base2
Powerhead compatible—Yes4Yes6Yes8—
Foam fineness—60 ppi440 ppi640 ppi8—
Air pump includedNo1———No1

How they compare

SpecificationOur pickHikari Bacto Surge SmallAquatop CAF-10 Internal Sponge FilterAquatop CAF-25 Internal Sponge FilterAquatop CAF-40 Internal Sponge FilterHikari Bacto Surge Large
Buy
Rated tank size40 gal1Up to 10 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 10 gallons for CAF-10.)3Up to 25 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 25 gallons for the selected CAF-25.)5Up to 40 gal (Configuration: Retailer-rated maximum: 40 gallons for CAF-40.)775 gal1
Base typeWeighted base2Weighted base4Weighted base6Weighted base8Weighted base2
Powerhead compatible—Yes4Yes6Yes8—
Foam fineness—60 ppi440 ppi640 ppi8—
Air pump includedNo1———No1

Sources

  1. hikariusa.com
  2. fishtankadvisor.com
  3. bluebarn.shop
  4. www.aquatop.com
  5. www.bluebarn.shop
  6. www.aquatop.com
  7. aqualabaquaria.com
  8. www.aquatop.com